HBO’s WATCHMEN and the Cyclical Nature of Racial Violence in America

The quasi-sequel to the seminal 1985 masterwork isn’t just a meditation on America’s current racial climate, but how that atmosphere is directly informed by America’s hidden past. *SPOILERS*

“Nothing ends, Adrian. Nothing ever ends.”

Those words, within the 12th issue of Alan Moore’s classic work of superhero metafiction, Doctor Manhattan sows the first seeds of doubt into the mind of Adrian Veidt, the World’s Smartest Man, after the latter has murdered millions of innocent people in an effort to save humankind from itself. It’s the first real sliver of insecurity in an otherwise totally confident mind, and it reinforces the central question of issue 12 (ironically titled ‘A Stronger Loving World’), which is whether or not Adrian Veidt’s plan can truly save humanity, or are we doomed to fall back into a cycle of destruction and violence due to our human nature?

Then came HBO’s Watchmen, a quasi-sequel to the original set in the modern day helmed by Damon Lindelof, which swaps out masked vigilantes for masked cops, Richard Nixon for Hollywood icon Robert Redford, and the looming threat of nuclear annihilation with the ever-present shadow of white supremacy. And it’s there, in this dichotomy, that we receive a response to the statement posed back in 1985. Nothing ever ends, truly, and this includes America’s natural-born relationship with its history of racial violence.

For context: HBO’s Watchmen follows the story of Sister Night, real name Angela Abar, a police officer in Tulsa, Oklahoma, where the cops wear masks to protect their identities in the aftermath of a domestic terrorist attack perpetrated against the Tulsa PD. The perpetrators? The Seventh Kavalry, a homegrown racist militia who were inspired by the publication of Rorschach’s Journal to don his mask and take up arms. The show’s central mystery is posed when Police Chief Judd Crawford is murdered by an unknown assailant at the end of the pilot episode.

Lindelof and his writers took very specific care to ingrain the show in America’s history much in the same way as the graphic novel, and one of the ways they did this was by opening the pilot episode with an on-the-ground depiction of the Tulsa massacre that occurred on May 31st, 1921, all from the eyes of a young boy named Will Reeves. For those who haven’t seen the show or aren’t aware, the Tulsa massacre was a horrific event in American history, in which a group of 1500 whites descended upon the Greenwood neighborhood of Tulsa and razed it to the ground, causing thousands of dollars worth of property damage. The Tulsa Police Department’s “official” tally of the dead was 36 people, including 10 whites. Before the massacre, Greenwood was an affluent neighborhood in which black Americans thrived and prospered. The area was even christened the “Black Wall-Street.” However, it took Greenwood years to rebuild in the face of the massacre, and Tulsa was never the same.

Within the universe of the show, the Tulsa massacre was eventually the defining event that led to the establishment of ‘Redfordations’ – a legislation that gave tax cuts to descendants of the people directly affected by the event. However, in the real world, the Tulsa race massacre was covered up and left unspoken for decades afterwards. The Tulsa Tribune, the local newspaper that inadvertently started the massacre by falsely reporting an alleged sexual assault of a white woman by a young black teenager, destroyed all recorded stories about the event from their bound volumes. Tulsa police and state militia archives about the incident were also decidedly omitted, causing teachings of the event to be left out of the American school system until very recently. In fact, it wasn’t until 1997 that an official state government commission was established to investigate the Tulsa riot. In 2001, an official published report from the Tulsa Race Massacre Commission concluded that between 100 and 300 black Americans were murdered during the event, an unfathomable leap from the originally reported 36.

The massacre looms heavy over the rest of the show, but it isn’t until episode 6, ‘This Extraordinary Being,’ that the event’s true relevance revealed itself to the show and to the mythos of Watchmen as a whole. Will Reeves, the young survivor of the Tulsa massacre and Angela’s recently discovered grandfather, is actually Hooded Justice, turned onto the path of vigilantism by the discovery that the New York police department that he worked for was filled to the brim with racial corruption. Hooded Justice, within the context of the original graphic novel, is the first costumed adventurer to spring onto the scene back in 1938 and directly inspired the Minutemen, and by proxy, the events of the book. His identity was never revealed in-universe as he disappeared shortly after the disbanding of the Minutemen, and speculation surrounded him in fan circles right up until the show premiered.

This is a massive change to the lore of Moore and Gibbons’ original book, one that fits neatly in the blank space left by his character, and one that is fraught with implications of appropriation as survival and white hegemony. The idea that a bisexual black man, angry at the world for its vicious treatment of him, directly inspired the actions of costumed vigilantes for the next five decades is a powerful one, and a strikingly ironic parallel to the now-infamous 2017 interview in which Alan Moore states that superheroes are white supremacist power fantasies. However, I think the most noteworthy implication of Will’s vigilantism and trauma is the effect that it may have indirectly had on Angela, as part of the recurring nature of America’s past.

There have been several studies, the most recent examining the connective tissue between survivors of Civil War POW camps and their descendants, that seem to suggest that a history of trauma and PTSD can be passed down through generations, creating an effect on both mental and physical health. It’s worth noting that these studies aren’t conclusive by any means, but there’s enough evidence to suggest the possibility that trauma may be embedded in the DNA of your descendants, and if that’s the case, is it possible that young black Americans hold that very same trauma within our DNA? That experiences shared by our ancestors shape our views of the world to this very day? And if that’s the case, is the implication that our experiences will shape our descendants?

Can this same argument be made about Angela and Will? Did Will’s experiences in the 30s lead to Angela’s current day temperament? Did the mask Will donned back then lead to the mask Angela wears now? Both of them, transcending decades, have fought against racial violence and white supremacy, and both of them have tried to find healing and catharsis through violence and anger. And while black retaliation is justified, it seems as if the show argues that living in that anger only leads to more pain. It seems that the final question the show leaves us with, moreso than whether or not Manhattan’s powers really were in that egg, is whether or not there’s a way for them to escape the trauma that they now both share?

On top of this, there’s another side to the show’s depiction of America’s cyclical racial violence. While the Seventh Kavalry are depicted as racists hiding behind the familiar inkblot mask of everyone’s favorite proto-fascist vigilante, we discover in episode 6 that the Seventh Kavalry have a precursor in Cyclops, a racist offshoot organization of the KKK that Will discovered was rooted within the very foundation of the NYPD. In retaliation, Will tried his hardest to root them out, even going as far as to kill several of their high-ranking members and burn down the base of their operation. But unbeknownst to him, the organization festers, until he finds out that it’s been co-opted by none other than Senator Joe Keene and Chief Judd Crawford, the two engineers of the White Night attacks on police and the resulting masked cop legislation. Both Will and Angela learn the hard way that America’s past doesn’t die, it just resurfaces, more palatable but still just as sinister.

As we find out in the final three episodes, this time their plan is much larger in scale. “It’s a really difficult time to be a white man in America,” Keene tells Special Agent Laurie Blake, while getting ready to step into a prototype intrinsic field generator, one eerily familiar to the same machine built in Gila Flats, New Mexico over four decades earlier. “So I figured I’d become a blue one.” It’s hard to deny how eerily similar Keene’s phrasing sounds to rhetoric used by members of the alt-right, in their declaration that modern day progressive ideologies have made it increasingly dangerous to exist as a white man in America. From concerns about becoming the new minority to shouts of “you will not replace us,” young white men are becoming increasingly aggressive when faced with the fact that they’re no longer being catered to.

Moderates across both aisles will tell you that this is new. Conservatives will say that this started with Obama, that his “race pandering” and indulgence of “hate groups” like Black Lives Matter created a toxic miasma of racial tensions that didn’t exist before. Liberals will say that these groups felt emboldened by Donald Trump and his indulging of his nationalist fanbase; the Richard Spencers and David Dukes of the world. But the real truth, the ugly truth, is that, just like the Cyclops, racism in America never truly went away. These new hate groups might wear new faces, but the truth is they’re just new symptoms of the same institutional problem America has allowed to fester for years. The same police structure that allowed the Tulsa massacre is the same police structure now fostering the murder of young black men. These occurrences may be new to some people, but for black Americans, this hate, this hurt, this pain has always been there.

Despite being a mirror to our own twisted timeline, Watchmen offers no easy answers. Adrian Veidt dropped a fake alien on New York and killed millions, and still couldn’t put a dent in the inevitability of human nature. Will Reeves fought for years against racism and white superiority, only to discover that his age old enemy had morphed before his very eyes, like an inkblot on a Rorschach test. Everything cycles back in on itself, like the ouroboros, eating its own tail. And America, as it seems, is doomed to repeat itself again and again.

That is, unless we expose its history to the masses. If we refuse to allow the injustices perpetrated to go unknown and unnamed as they have. Just like the truth of the Tulsa massacre was revealed, almost 8 decades after it happened, the rest of America’s past needs to be exhumed and put under the microscope, to be examined, discussed, absorbed, and understood. For us to attempt to address our racial divide, we must first accept that it’s always been here. It didn’t start in 2016, it didn’t start in the 1960’s, and it didn’t start in Tulsa in 1921. America has always worn a mask to hide its true face from the world and it’s people.

And just like Will Reeves so beautifully said in the show’s final episode, “You can’t heal under a mask Angela. Wounds need air.”

-Chrishaun

Star Wars: Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker Review – A Disappointing and Creatively Bankrupt Conclusion

If the destiny of the Jedi is to confront fear, then a Jedi this film is certainly not

By the very nature of film in and of itself, one specific movie isn’t going to be for everyone. Films as spearheaded by directors are supposed to be unified by a vision; that already breeds a certain degree of niche due to not everyone’s tastes aligning. That’s why cult films exist, that’s why indie films exist, and even within those aspects of the medium there are individual subgenres because people are finicky and have individual likes and tastes.

Blockbusters are films that are engineered to appeal to as many people as possible. A traditional good vs evil moral structure, some bombastic and competently directed action-sequences, and maybe even a love story or two. Because blockbusters are designed to make money, large studios want to make sure that they can be as appealing to as many people as possible. However, even within the context of blockbusters, films have to be single-minded in their vision to make for compelling art. If not, the end result is a film that feels less like a director’s vision and more like a studio-committee misfire. There are examples of both of these; think The Dark Knight, Black Panther, Mission Impossible: Fallout, or conversely, Suicide Squad or The Amazing Spider-Man 2.

Despite it being the culmination of 9 films worth of storytelling, The Rise of Skywalker unfortunately falls in the category of the latter. It’s not nearly as bad as either of those examples, and ultimately, the movie does have the embellishments that make it feel like a JJ Abrams film, but at the end of the day, Episode 9 suffers from trying too hard to appeal to too many people, as a reaction to fan sentiments over The Last Jedi.

First off: the good. Abrams truly does nail the sense of wonder and world-building Star Wars is known for. Each new location feels unique, yet also feels like the exact kind of place that would fit comfortably in the ever-expanding galaxy. The new characters that we meet, including Naomi Ackie’s Jannah and Kerri Russell’s Zorii Bliss, all feel like intriguing new additions to the Star Wars canon, even if we don’t spend that much time with each of them. And par the course for the sequel trilogy, the action sequences have been exceptionally well-choreographed and shot, from the lightsaber duels to the galactic-scale dogfights the series has become so known for. The Rise of Skywalker lives and breathes Star Wars in its feel and aesthetic, and for better or worse that commitment to this “traditional idea” of Star Wars runs throughout the film (more on that later).

My favorite part of the sequel trilogy thusfar has undoubtedly been the chemistry of the main cast, and it’s awesome seeing the three of them finally together as a unit on-screen. Despite my love for The Last Jedi and my understanding of why the trio was broken up narratively, Skywalker indulges in the strength of it’s leads. John Boyega, Daisy Ridley, and Oscar Isaac all have unique traits and quirks that they bring to each of their characters, and seeing them bounce off of each other was easily the most enjoyable part of the film to me.

Another aspect of Skywalker that was unexpectedly well-done was the inclusion of Carrie Fisher. Since her unfortunate and timely passing at the tail-end of 2016, there’s been a massive question mark in the air about the inclusion of Princess Leia in the final film. And to me, this movie provides context for her in a very tasteful manner, both respectful of Fisher as a real-life personality, as well as her character. The spirit of Leia endures throughout the Skywalker saga and the conclusion does a lovely job at honoring that legacy.

I only wish that the rest of the movie could be as thoughtful. However, that isn’t the case. In his desperation to please the wide berth of Star Wars fans, JJ Abrams has made a movie that’s both narratively flawed and just honestly soulless. Despite the highs, The Rise of Skywalker feels like the equivalent of having the entirety of /r/StarWars and /r/PrequelMemes attempt to write a satisfying conclusion. There are glaring storytelling problems here outside of the mindless fan-service. Several important hinging plot points are contrived and rely on sheer convenience to make sense, and even then they’re barely coherent. And the plot, when it does connect like a story should, relies on several McGuffins and magical plot items back to back to back. It’s as if Chris Terrio (the writer of BvS and Justice League, might I add) and Abrams suddenly forgot how to write an intricate and original screenplay. And if that wasn’t enough, the entire storyline of the film feels like it was lifted straight from early drafts of the Original Trilogy. There were major complaints that The Force Awakens was too derivative of A New Hope, and while I was a vehement defender of TFA at the time, TROS just feels like Abrams conceding that he did, in fact, rip-off the entire OT.

Because of the film’s desperate nature to placate the most banal wishes of the fanbase, several twists and revelations occur involving major characters in the film, most notably Rey and Kylo Ren. Specifically what the movie does to Rey’s journey of self-discovery is a massive step back in terms of her arc, and really undermines the steps she takes towards finding herself in both TFA and TLJ. In fact, Skywalker spends a lot of time trying to undermine and walk back developments made in The Last Jedi, be it out of a misplaced sense of obligation to its detractors or Abrams feeling like the movie didn’t personally pursue the plot threads that he set up for in TFA. The most glaring example of this is the movie’s sidelining of Rose Tico, the plucky engineer turned Resistance hero who has an entire storyline with Finn in the previous film. Skywalker regulates her to essentially a background extra with barely three speaking lines.

On top of these, the most egregious (and also hilarious) problem in The Rise 0f Skywalker is Palpatine’s return. Heralded by the first trailer (and also, shockingly, a canon voice appearance in Fortnite), Sheev Palpatine’s resurrection and subsequent appearance in this final film was the subject of much fan debate and speculation. Is it really him? Is it a Force ghost jumping bodies? Was he ever really dead in the first place? And if the movie was attempting to answer these questions, the only true response it gives is essentially a big shrug. Nothing surrounding his resurfacing is ever truly explained. The movie just starts by telling the audience that he’s back in the opening crawl, and Kylo Ren goes to visit him only to find him chilling on an ancient Sith planet with an army of Star Destroyers. There’s even a part towards the third act of the film (I won’t spoil the context) where he suddenly just has a legion of Sith admirers cheering him on in a stadium that looks suspiciously like the Rose Bowl. It’s simultaneously hilarious and depressing at the same time.

I so desperately wanted The Rise of Skywalker to be a worthy conclusion to the Skywalker legacy. Despite many OG Star Wars fans, I’ve loved the sequel trilogy up to this point, and I truly believe that both The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi are fantastic, albeit thematically different, blockbusters. But on a narrative and thematic level, The Rise of Skywalker is a major disappointment for not just the sequel trilogy but the entire franchise at this point. While there’s a lot to enjoy, the movie just doesn’t try to engage its audience in any meaningful or daring way, like Lucas did with his beloved originals and even the maligned prequels. The Rise of Skywalker is just a hollow, vapid movie, with nothing to say aside from desperate pleas of “do you like this? PLEASE tell me you like this!”

The Rise of Skywalker gets ★★1/2 out of ★★★★★

-Chrishaun

Queen and Slim and Legacy Through Community

Alongside following their intimate journey, Melina Matsoukas’ romantic crime-thriller uses its two leads as powerful examples of modern-day martyrdom. *Spoilers Ahead*


“Eyes wellin’ up with tears/Thinking ’bout my niggas dead in the dirt/Immortalized on a shirt-“

These lyrics from J. Cole’s Immortal ran through my head several times as I watched the heartbreaking but inevitable conclusion of Queen and Slim, an uneven yet resonant ride through the deep South and America’s racial foundation. Over the movie’s two and a half hour long runtime, we watch as Angela ‘Queen’ Johnson and Ernest ‘Slim’ Hines kill a police officer in self-defense, and then make a desperate break for Cuba rather than stay and face a corrupt investigation. Wearing the Bonnie and Clyde title proudly on its sleeve, it’s no surprise then that the movie ends with our two protagonists brutally gunned down in a hail of gunfire, before showcasing the collective mourning done by the black community in response.

It’s a scene that’s both agonizing to watch and all too familiar to anyone with black skin. Watching the funeral sequence, complete with black shirts emblazoned with the likenesses of the deceased, felt like a story ripped from the headlines. Indeed, Black America has watched in solidarity as similar vigils have been held for Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown, Eric Garner, the list goes on and on and on. But Queen and Slim takes that narrative and turns it in a resilient direction.

Earlier in the film, on their way to another in a line of safe houses waiting to take in the falsely-accused outlaws, Angela and Earnest find themselves in a philosophical conversation regarding what the both of them expect out of a relationship. When it’s his turn to answer, Ernest provides a response that is arguably the thesis of the entire film: legacy.

“I ain’t tryna bend the world. As long as my lady remembers me fondly, that’s all I need.”

Queen and Slim not only takes the audience on a journey with our two central characters, but it also spends a decent chunk of time examining how the two outlaws interact with other people and how the changing social landscape reacts to them. We see them through the eyes of several different people, including Angela’s own uncle (a man with his own mired past), but arguably the most interesting and tragic set of eyes that we see the two characters through are those of Junior, a young black boy that they meet on their way to Miami, Florida. He’s the son of a mechanic whom the two ask to fix their car, and while his father is disillusioned and downright disproving of their actions, Junior is a different story entirely.

Through dialogue between the three of them, we find out that Junior views Angela and Ernest as heroes, and is planning on attending a march in their honor. When asked why, he simply tells them that because of their struggle, even if they die, they’ll become immortal. Junior also desires to be immortal as well, and he unfortunately receives his wish when he shockingly decides to shoot a police officer at the march he’s attending, causing him to be gunned down himself in turn. It’s a radical shift in the movie’s course, one that’s even more divisive when you realize that it’s juxtaposed against Queen and Slim’s first lovemaking scene in the film. Despite being jarring, and honestly ill-fitting, I believe this juxtaposition is meant to represent the birth of their legacy: conceived in passion yet marked through pain and strife. For better or for worse, their actions have caused a seismic shift in the black community within the film.

Because the movie starts with their first date, we get the pleasure of watching Angela and Ernest grow closer to each other through their circumstance: from an awkward Tinder meetup to star-crossed lovers. And it’s because of their situation that this transformation occurs. Not saying that black love can only be borne out of suffering, because that’s not what the movie is saying, but I believe that on some subconscious level the film’s script seems to be suggesting that the black experience is universal in relation to each other, and the connection afforded to Angela and Ernest is one that is rooted in their shared understanding of their place in the world. Queen and Slim end up in the situation that they do because of their skin color, and they endure in the face of their circumstances because of the connection provided by that unique black experience. Lena Waithe said that the script is about the transformative power of black love, and the movie truly makes a case for that in how the love they grow to find in each other allows them to transcend their circumstance, even when all is lost.

Which brings me back to the very closing shot of the film. A group of kids, in what seems to be a few months or even years into the future, stencil a massive mural of a picture taken of Queen and Slim on their run for freedom. It’s silent, no dialogue save for the ambiance of kids at play, but it’s powerful. It’s powerful and yet familiar, in the exact same way as the “In Memoriam” shirts that every black family in America has seen at least one of. It’s legacy, memory made tangible through our universal and yet unique relationship with each other.

Just like so many young lives that have been snuffed out in the cog of American racism, the memories of Angela and Ernest are promised to live on through those who can relate to the black experience. Queen and Slim may never have made it to Cuba, the same way that so African-Americans in the real world never get the chance to live life to the fullest, but they’re kept alive in the culture that nourishes us, in the environment that breeds us, and in the community that fosters our revolution.

Knives Out Review – A Whodunnit That Ranks as One of the Best to Have Ever Dunnit

I’d honestly give this movie five stars solely for Daniel Craig and that thick Southern drawl

Oh Rian Johnson. You wonderful, incredible, visionary filmmaker you. I’ve been in love with you since the moment I saw Looper, your first foray into science-fiction. Chock full of black humor, wonderful performances, and tight world-building, I could never imagine a better feature debut for a budding writer-director. And then I discovered that it wasn’t your first film, and so I took a trip back in time to 2005 with Brick, which quickly became one of my favorites of all time. With it’s electric dialogue and intricate screenplay, you turned the noir genre inside out and crafted a present of all of my sensibilities as a film lover, and even gift-wrapped it.

Photo by Anthony Harvey/Shutterstock (10439063a) Rian Johnson ‘Knives Out’ premiere, BFI London Film Festival, UK – 08 Oct 2019

Then came The Last Jedi, and the vitriol that arrived with it. I simply couldn’t imagine why such a methodical, passionate and loving examination of Star Wars was followed by such hate and spitefulness, but little did I know that the reaction to The Last Jedi was almost as much of an exercise in thematic relevance as the movie itself. Weeks turned to months turned to years, and The Last Jedi was still the gift that kept on giving: one of the best examples of life imitating art in its critique of how the Star Wars legacy must reconcile its past with its future if it wants to continue innovating and expanding.

And as if that wasn’t enough, you come around and give me this? This?? With Knives Out (only your fifth film, you absolute maniac), Rian Johnson continues to prove that he’s one of the most understated yet dynamic filmmakers working in Hollywood today. Using the well-worn frame story of the whodunnit murder-mystery as a vehicle, Knives Out is a shot of adrenaline that can only be found at the movies, bursting at the seams with a massive ensemble cast, an unmatched knowledge of genre tropes as well as the balls to flip them on their heads, more meta-referential comedy than you can shake a Joss Whedon script at, and one of the best critiques of America’s current political atmosphere that I’ve seen in quite a long time.

Whodunnit’s are typically quite plot heavy, and it seems like a lot of them get caught in the rut of reinventing the wheel or playing around with traditional plot tropes that aren’t as original as they’re thought to be. On the contrary, Knives Out has a unique setup that only continues to spiral further into uncharted territory. We follow Marta (anchored by a stellar performance from Ana de Armas), a young undocumented immigrant from Ecuador who works as a caretaker for Harlan Thrombey (Christopher Plummer), an acclaimed crime novelist sitting on top of a literal fortune made on the backs of his novels. Things start to fall apart, however, when Harlan is found dead of an apparent suicide and his colorful (re: dysfunctional) family shows up in an effort to lay claim to his assets. The movie wastes absolutely no time in taking what you THINK you know about the case and flipping it upside down, and then just when you think you’ve acclimated to the new direction the movie seems to be going in, it flips you again, and again, and again, until you’re sitting in the audience with vertigo and a killer headache from trying to wrap your brain around the inevitable conclusion that you couldn’t have seen coming.

That is most definitely not a criticism, however. Rian Johnson is very clearly a fan of the murder-mystery, as he takes painful care never to lose the audience amidst the movie’s many twists and turns. While the conclusion may leave you awestruck at how sheerly impossible it is to predict, the screenplay is the film’s greatest asset, in that nearly every throwaway line comes back with a vengeance in the end. There’s arguably not a single plot thread in this movie that isn’t cataclysmically important by the end of it, which is simply a testament to how strong of a screenwriter Johnson is. He truly understands the importance of a well-timed pocket, and he never underestimates how diligent and how attentive his audience is.

Aside from the screenplay, the ensemble cast is easily the strongest and most well-utilized part of the film. Ana de Armas is at her A-game here, bringing a humanity and a vulnerability to her character of Marta that makes her a truly authentic portrayal of an undocumented immigrant on-screen, one that isn’t focused entirely on her suffering and her status. Also, her character has an incredibly unique and hilarious quirk that, without spoiling it, is not only played for laughs but is legitimately integral to the plot progression of the movie. Alongside her, Daniel Craig gives an absolutely magnificent performance as Benoit Blanc, Johnson’s entirely original private investigator with a Southern disposition. Seeing him unravel the mystery of Harlan Thrombey’s demise is such a joy to watch, partly because he’s such an intensely human and likeable character, and partly because you can tell that Craig is having a blast bringing him to life. Rian Johnson has expressed interest in quasi-sequels to Knives Out following the exploits of Blanc’s character, and I can say for certain that it would be a shame if we never get to see more of the super-sleuth.

The rest of the cast is firing on all cylinders as well, most of them playing several colorful members of the Thrombey dynasty. We’ve got Chris Evans, Jamie Lee Curtis, Michael Shannon, Toni Collette, Don Johnson, Riki Lindhome, hell, even Katherine Langford and Jaden Lieberher all bringing these characters to life. I won’t go into who plays who, simply because I feel like all their introductions in the film are so bombastic that seeing them on-screen for the first time is a treat in and of itself. Just know that there isn’t a single sub-par performance in this movie, and we even get an appearance by Lakeith Stanfield as the Detective Lieutenant assigned to the case.

KO_08116.dng

All of these moving pieces would be enough by themselves to sell the film, but it’s the allegorical heart of Knives Out that really tethers everything together. Proving once again what a master he is at writing with theme as the intent, Rian Johnson crafts the movie’s whodunnit narrative around the simple idea of white entitlement and nativism. Despite being a movie written within the zeitgeist of 2019 (don’t be shocked when you hear the words “SJW” and “alt-right troll” thrown around liberally), the movie never beats you over the head with its political commentary, choosing to remain subtle and understated for most of the film’s runtime. In fact, it really isn’t until the shotgun blast of a final shot that Johnson fully unveils the scope of his masterpiece; a scathing critique of American idealism and birthright, one that sticks a middle finger directly at those who believe America belongs to a certain skin color or social status. Rian Johnson sees you, sees your racist tirades and xenophobic biases, and he’s only got one thing to say.

“Eat shit. Eat shit, eat shit, eat shit…definitely eat shit.”

Knives Out gets a WELL-deserved ★★★★★ out of ★★★★★ stars.

-Chrishaun

El Camino (Spoiler) Review – An Unsurprisingly Excellent Return to ABQ

As if Vince Gilligan didn’t have enough to brag about already…

If you weren’t living underneath a rock from January 2008 until September 2013, then you’ve probably heard of Breaking Bad. And if you unfortunately HAVE been under a rock, then get the hell out from under it and catch up on television. A slick crime-thriller/family drama/dark comedy, the show followed the shenanigans of chemistry teacher-turned-drug kingpin Walter White, after making the totally normal decision to sell crystal meth in order to provide for his family in the wake of his cancer diagnosis. It’s seriously one of the greatest television shows of all-time, charting the transformation of a well-intentioned man into a power-hungry monster, with the audience’s reactions ranging from “he’s providing for his family” to “this dude needs the chair.”

“If there’s one thing I know for sure, it’s that you can’t trust bald dudes.”

And caught up in the midst of Walter White’s mad scramble for power is Jesse Pinkman, a young high school dropout who introduces the teacher into the meth game. For five seasons Jesse is dragged around, corrupted (further), manipulated, and brutalized as Walt’s obsession with becoming infamous reaches dangerous heights, and we watch as their relationship writhes and shifts from a casual partnership to a brotherly connection to a father/son relationship, and finally, two estranged frenemies watching their empire collapse around them.

And it is here that El Camino – A Breaking Bad Movie picks up. It’s hard to discuss the events of the film without talking about where the show leaves Jesse at, so *SPOILER ALERT* for anyone who hasn’t finished Breaking Bad (shameful). I won’t go too heavy into the nitty-gritty of everything else that happens towards the tail-end of Season 5, but for context, Walt’s illicit dealings bring him into a circle of white supremacist gangsters, and after a particularly nasty falling out between him and his partner, Walt allows the neo-Nazis to kidnap and torture Jesse before his conscience gets the better of them. Walt busts Jesse out of the compound in spectacular fashion, and the last we see of Jesse Pinkman at the end of Breaking Bad is a single shot of him ramming through the gated fence surrounding the area, with a combined expression of joy, relief, remorse, regret, and uncertainty all plain on his face.

Until El Camino, which picks up right after the end of the show. I think, for me, the greatest asset of the film is how effortlessly it drops back in where the show leaves off. Nobody who hasn’t finished Breaking Bad is going to bother watching what is in essence a direct sequel to it (unless they’re channeling the chaotic energy of The Joker), so for returning fans there’s an immediate sense of familiarity and comfort in a way that doesn’t feel like it’s pandering or condescending to us. There’s been a big conversation surrounding the movie about whether or not it’s necessary, whether or not we need a return to the world populated by these characters. With this, and with Better Call Saul (which I unfortunately have not watched), I think the answer would be a resounding: no. No, these supplements are not necessary to the story told in five seasons by Breaking Bad. However, this isn’t a knock against them. While these stories aren’t necessarily necessary, that doesn’t mean they aren’t welcomed with open arms. El Camino and (from what I’ve heard) BCS are both projects that won’t malign the ending of BB, but also are worthy additions to the canon of the show because they provide stories that are riveting and worth telling on their own and as additions to the show.

And that story being told is one that is emotionally powerful when tethered to the end of the show. The stakes are low and simple. Jesse Pinkman, having recently escaped captivity at the hands of his abusers, is trying to find a way out of Albuquerque. For good. However, he’s got to contend with the law, thugs and gangsters, as well his own shredded morality and PTSD trying to hold him back.

That’s a lot to latch onto, especially as an actor, but luckily Aaron Paul is at the top of his game here. After the end of Breaking Bad he’s made appearances in several films and television shows, all of which he does a great job in, but I’ve always felt like Jesse Pinkman will be the role to beat for him and he proves it once again here. Despite the overwhelmingly difficult place Jesse finds himself escaping from at the end of the show, Vince Gilligan finds a way to write Pinkman as such so that his victimization doesn’t overwhelm the character. Instead, we watch as Aaron Paul struggles with the memories of his time in imprisonment, we watch as those memories haunt and terrorize him, but at the same time the Jesse we know and love throughout the show still shines out. Instead of turning him simply into a depressed and introverted shell of who he formerly was (which would have been easy to do), both Gilligan and Paul give us a version of the character caught in-between two transitional phases: the end of the tragic life he lived under the grip of Walt and the beginning of his own.

Not content with just bringing back Aaron Paul to lead, however, El Camino packs itself full of other returning characters from Breaking Bad. Now, don’t go into the movie expecting to see Gus Fring or Walter White himself. Despite being a sequel, El Camino knows how to manage its returning cameos in a way that doesn’t feel like fan-service. Each time we see a familiar face, it’s warranted within the context of both the ending of Breaking Bad as well as the story being told within El Camino.

The atmosphere of the film manages its relation to Breaking Bad perfectly. It’s shot and edited to feel like an episode of the show, along with some cinematic flourishes. The entire project really grasps the weight of its existence as an epilogue, resolving stories that need resolving while avoiding that age-old instinct to open up new ones, “just in-case.” Everything about El Camino truly feels like an ending, from Jesse discussing what he would do if he could get out of the meth business in an opening flashback, to the show’s bated breath mention of Brock Cantillo as an ever-present reminder of the cost of Jesse’s mistakes. While Breaking Bad charts the question of what it takes to drive a good man cruel, El Camino sidesteps this and asks a question of it’s own: can someone ever truly escape the shadow of the things they’ve done? I think I know the answer, but for the sake of preserving that mystery for everyone else, I’ll just suggest that you watch it and find out for yourself.

While Breaking Bad has a perfect ending in and of itself, El Camino simply adds a footnote onto it and a proper conclusion for one of the greatest characters ever written onto a television screen. Conversations about the necessity and the need for this movie are irrelevant; Vince Gilligan decided he had one last thing to say and he said it. And the result is a film that manages to provide something fresh to one of the best television stories ever told, as well as standing on its own as a whip-smart crime-thriller.

El Camino gets ★★★★ out of ★★★★★

-Chrishaun

Arthur Fleck’s One Bad Day

How Todd Phillips’ Joker manages to both examine and rebuke the killer clown’s famous ideology from Batman: The Killing Joke. Spoilers ensue.

“All it takes is one bad day to reduce the sanest man alive to lunacy. That’s how far the world is from where I am. Just one bad day.”

There’s Joker stories, and then there’s The Killing Joke. Written in 1988 by resident comic book legend (and wizard) Alan Moore and illustrated by Brian Bolland, it’s simultaneously a deep probe into the pathology of The Joker as well as the complex relationship that he has with Batman (it’s also considered one of the most misogynistic comic books of all-time, however that’s another essay for another time). It’s been referenced, adapted, and homaged countless times due to the possible origin that it gives the character of The Joker, and despite the abundance of other seminal works regarding him as a character, The Killing Joke is first and foremost always considered the greatest.

Now, as of October 2019, there is Joker. A standalone film released underneath what may become a DC Black film label, Joker is a period piece set in the early 80s that follows failed stand-up comedian Arthur Fleck’s descent into moral corruption and madness as Gotham’s sociopolitical landscape fails him. Sound familiar? Aside from the obvious parallels between Arthur’s attempts at stand-up and The Joker’s in TKJ, there’s a wealth of parallels to the character’s pathology, ideology, and ultimate relationship to Gotham’s Dark Knight that both the movie and the comic share. This isn’t to say that Joker is the definitive cinematic take on the character; quite the contrary, as the beauty of The Joker as a character is that he refuses to be tied down by one origin, by one incarnation, by one personality. However, I believe that the film has a very specific trajectory in mind, one that’s dominated by The Joker’s personal crusade within The Killing Joke.

For context, what exactly is The Joker’s ideology in The Killing Joke? Well, the plot goes as this. Tired of his back and forth, push and pull conflict with Batman, The Joker decides to bring in some new blood to the party in an effort to teach Batman what it’s like to be him once and for all. His targets? Jim and Barbara Gordon. The Joker (recently escaped from Arkham Asylum) shows up to Gordon’s house, and when Barbara answers the door, he shoots her in the spine, paralyzing her. He then kidnaps Commissioner Gordon, chains him up to a carnival fun-ride, and after (potentially) dosing him with LSD, forces him to look at graphic photos of Barbara’s nude and wounded body. Why? Aside from it all simply being a sick joke to him, like it usually is, this time The Joker has a point. He wants to prove to both Gordon, and by extension Batman, that all it takes is “one bad day” to drive even the most moral and justified human being to insanity.

The reason for this is found within the potential origin offered up by The Killing Joke. The Joker was once a man named Jack, a soon-to-be father trying his hand at stand-up comedy in order to provide for his family. However, Jack soon finds himself at the end of his rope, and in his desperation agrees to escort two criminals through the chemical plant that he previously worked at, in order to find the secret entrance to a playing card shop next door which they intend to rob. As you can predict, things go horribly wrong. The criminals tell Jack that his wife and unborn child have died in an accident, and when he tries to back out, they force him into the guise of the notorious career thief the Red Hood, in an attempt to set him up as a fall-man in case they get caught. Once they arrive at the plant, things go from bad to worse as the security guards on the clock catch, shoot, and kill the other criminals. Jack tries to get away but is cornered at the last second by Batman, who scares him enough to dive into a vat of chemicals in order to get away. He does, but in a tragic twist of fate, he’s horribly disfigured by his toxic swim, and as a result of the emotional and physical gauntlet he just experienced, the man known as Jack suffers an acute mental breakdown.

Joker’s ideology is simple. He was once a rational man, driven to the brink by a mixture of societal ills and situational despair, both events outside of his control. And now, as The Joker, he believes that the cosmic irony of the universe is that madness is only one step away. That anyone, under the right circumstances, can become just like him.

Which brings us back to Todd Phillips’ Joker. Arthur Fleck, despite his ailments and disposition, is seemingly an average man. He functions; he has a job, a mother whom he cares about deeply, and he tries his hand at his dream of stand-up comedy. He even meets a girl in his apartment complex, Sophie, that he strikes up a relationship with. Unfortunately, Arthur is exactly the type of man that a city like Gotham beats into the dirt. He’s routinely assaulted and robbed, he’s not valued in the slightest at his job, and his state sponsored therapy program has just recently been cut off by the higher ups. Arthur is trapped in a hell that’s only just beginning to get hotter.

Over the course of the movie, we watch as his life spirals even further out of control. He’s fired from his job after he’s spotted with a gun given to him by one of his coworkers. Later that night, he’s ambushed and beaten by a group of rich interns from Wayne Enterprises, which is the straw that breaks the camel’s back. Arthur shoots and kills all three of them, an event that inspires a series of riots across Gotham from poor men and women tired of the gross class inequality in the city. After this, Arthur discovers from his ailing mother that he might be the illegitimate son of Thomas Wayne, one of Gotham’s wealthiest residents and potential mayoral candidate. He goes to visit his potential father, who roundly rejects him and his mother. He’s even rejected by his other father figure, a comedy talk show host named Murray Franklin who Arthur has looked up to the entirety of the film. Franklin airs footage of Arthur’s ill-fated stand-up routine and mocks him in front of all of Gotham City.

To make matters worse, he visits Arkham Asylum, where he discovers that his mother was once a patient there after being caught allowing random men to abuse her son, trauma that may have led to Arthur’s unstable laughing condition. These events all serve to drive Arthur further into despair and isolation. He smothers his mother in the hospital and begins his transition into The Joker.

Now there are some criticisms that the movie sympathizes with Arthur’s plight and his resulting actions. These criticisms aren’t unfounded; the class riots in Gotham are directly caused by Arthur, but that entire subplot is generally misguided, mishandled, and juvenile. Even Sophie’s character tells Arthur directly at one point that she thinks the man who killed the Wall Street kids is a hero. However, I believe that the movie intentionally avoids sympathizing with Arthur for two major reasons.

First off, the movie is told through Arthur’s lens, who is an unreliable narrator. There are several instances of him hallucinating and day-dreaming, the biggest of which being his entire relationship with Sophie. She’s a fabrication of his mind. She doesn’t actually know him outside of a conversation they had in an elevator. Arthur’s entire mental state is unstable, so of course he would seemingly believe that he’s justified in his actions and response to the world’s treatment of him. Secondly, I think a big misconception is that the movie sympathizes with Arthur because it humanizes him. This is naive and unfounded. Arthur isn’t justified because we see him and the tribulations he goes through before everything happens. Walter White’s actions aren’t justified or sympathetic simply because he has cancer. Audiences are capable of understanding without condoning. The way the movie frames Arthur prior to his transformation is more along the lines of a ticking time-bomb; somebody who exists within society with all the makings of a killer, and is driven to do so by societal conditions. Despite the fact that he’s been abused and mistreated by the world, his response is still morally reprehensible.

Which is the crux of my argument, in that Joker is directly inspired by The Killing Joke‘s ideology. Arthur is someone who believes that since he was the butt of life’s grand joke, he’s now going to turn life into his punching bag. “One bad day” drove Arthur into a lifetime of morally corrupt and irresponsible decisions, and instead of accepting responsibility for his behavior, he blames everyone else but himself. In fact, he directly says it in the movie. “Everyone is awful these days. It’s enough to make anybody crazy.”

Just like The Killing Joke, the movie also provides an exact rebuke of this pathology, and his name is Batman. Or in Joker‘s case, the implication of Batman. The movie’s third act reveals that the Waynes were murdered as a result of a massive clown riot inspired by Arthur’s killing of Murray Franklin on live television. One of the final shots of the film is an iconic image: Bruce, standing in the middle of the lifeless bodies of his parents, with Arthur speaking to his Arkham therapist in the background: “I just thought of a joke. But you wouldn’t get it.” Arthur’s joke is his belief that the death of Bruce’s parents will drive him just as crazy as Arthur.

But as anyone who has even a passing knowledge of the character is aware, Bruce does the exact opposite. He turns his trauma into a crusade against the exact kind of violence that Arthur perpetuates. Instead of falling victim to the same cycle of toxicity and violence that begets Arthur’s transformation into The Joker, Bruce begins a new cycle, one that culminates in his transformation into…Batman. The polar opposite and mirror image of The Joker. Two sides of basic human nature.

I think, for the most part, Joker is a naive movie with a lack of nuance in the social themes that it attempts to pursue. Its class inequality is black and white, and its depiction of mental illness is vague and arguably hollow. But I think the best part of the film is its understanding of what makes The Joker who he is (according to one interpretation, anyway), as well as the duality of his relationship with the boy who inevitably becomes the Bat. Joker doesn’t seek to sympathize or romanticize the character. Instead, it seeks to examine how each of us reacts in the face of extreme social turmoil, and what we all decide to do with our “one bad day.”

-Chrishaun

Joker Review – A Confused, Chaotic and Undercooked Approach to a Classic Character

Not the incel-rallying powder keg it was made out to be, nor the genre-redefining masterpiece so desperately hoped for

The Joker, introduced in the debut issue of Batman (April 25, 1940), has been a pop-culture mainstay since his chilling grin first showed up on the gloss-coated covers of comic books in newsstands. He’s been a continued fascination in the pantheon of fictional villains, and it seems like no matter what, no interpretation of the Caped Crusader can emerge unscathed without facing his greatest nemesis. Some of the greatest performers in the film medium have cut their teeth on the character, from Cesar Romero’s cackling trickster to Jack Nicholson’s sinister Mafioso to Heath Ledger’s endlessly quotable homegrown terrorist to whatever the heck Jared Leto was doing in 2016.

Now it’s Joaquin Phoenix’s turn in 2019’s Joker, a movie that pays more homage to the grit and psychological decay of classic Scorsese films than the camp of the character’s early appearances. This movie, directed by Todd Phillips of Hangover Trilogy fame, is very clear about the fact that it’s different from any other superhero movie before it. In fact, its reluctance to be associated with standard superhero film fare is part of the controversy stirred up before the movie’s release. Alongside that, the media was also in fear of the possibility of a mass-shooting related to the film’s release, due to the character’s popularity among certain hate groups, as well as the misattribution of the tragic Aurora Colorado shooting to the character.

So it seems like the real question is whether or not the movie lives up to either of its pre-release expectations. And in my opinion, it does not. Make no mistake about it, Joker is pretty good. It has moments where it’s great, actually. But it’s not an incendiary and dangerous rallying cry for self-victimizing hate-mongers, and it’s also not the transformative cinematic experience it was hyped up to be. It’s simply a good character study that attempts to bite off more than it can chew.

This interpretation of Joker takes place in the 80’s, and the character is re-imagined as a psychologically disturbed Gothamite named Arthur Fleck, at the height of a period of economic and social turmoil for the fictional city. He has dreams of a career in stand-up comedy, but is grounded by his duty to provide for his ailing mother, as well as a rare pathological disorder that causes him to burst into fits of painful laughter, a condition which routinely gets him beaten up and ostracized. All of these issues begin to overwhelm Arthur amidst the backdrop of the rising class inequality in Gotham, and slowly but surely Arthur becomes a ticking time-bomb of unfathomable violence and moral corruption in the aftermath of one horrifying moment.

As an exploration of the character first and foremost, Joker succeeds. Arthur is a man who’s victimized and abused by a society that refuses to acknowledge him, and the movie does a good job at understanding his plight without sympathizing him or condoning his actions. He’s a disturbed man with a particularly vengeful disposition, and so when his rage bubbles over to the surface we’re simply left to reflect on how things could’ve been avoided. And on the performance side of things, Joaquin Phoenix captures this essence beautifully. His Arthur really is someone who’s gone through the absolute ringer and he looks the part: Phoenix lost 52 pounds in preparation for playing this depiction of The Joker. He’s emaciated, bruised and battered, and when Arthur finally decides that enough is enough we really get the feeling that he’s someone that’s been chewed up and spat out by the world.

The supporting cast is also good, but by definition this is a character study of Arthur’s descent into madness and moral corruption, so they naturally don’t have as much to do. The two centerpieces of the wider ensemble are Zazie Beetz as Sophie, a young single mother who lives in Arthur’s apartment complex, and Robert De Niro as Murray Franklin, a popular talk show host who Arthur aspires to emulate and become. These two people inadvertently help to shape the conditions that lead to Arthur’s spiral downwards, and both of them give solid performances that otherwise could easily just fade into the background of the film. However they both manage to stand out and give you pause to think about their place in the movie long after the credits roll.

Aside from the performances, the technical aspects of Joker are firing on all cylinders. The cinematography, courtesy of Lawrence Sher, who’s worked with director Todd Phillips many times in the past, conjures up a grainy, gritty look at an 80’s Gotham that feels much less Tim Burton-esque and more grimy New York City. When the camera is focused on Arthur we get intimate and involved close-ups, a focus that boxes the audience in with our villainous protagonist and force us to get inside his head. On the flip side, Hildur Guðnadóttir crafts a hypnotic and haunting score, one that mimics Arthur’s fall and The Joker’s rise with beautiful, disturbing melody.

It would seem like all the parts that craft a wonderful film are present in Joker, and you would certainly be forgiven for thinking it’s a perfect movie on the outside, but once you break into the real meat of Joker the problem becomes disturbingly apparent: the script is not very good. In fact, it feels like a first draft of what could’ve become a promising screenplay.

While Arthur’s descent into madness and villainy is captured pretty well, that’s because of the fact that the lead performer is an incredibly experienced actor, as well as the fact that The Joker is a multi-layered character with decades worth of material to pull and draw from. On top of this is the fact that Todd Phillips was heavily inspired by Scorsese films such as Taxi Driver and The King of Comedy, movies that also track a descent into madness by certain characters. This provides him with a rough trajectory of where this version will take the character. However, a lot of the themes poked at by the film, such as mental illness and society’s treatment of it, as well as class and wealth inequality, are just done in a really juvenile way. None of the wider social issues at play in the movie really get time to develop, and because of this, lack any kind of nuance or authenticity. They feel there for the sake of having a tumultuous background for Gotham as opposed to making any kind of statement.

The script also extends right down into the heart of the film, cluttering it with bad dialogue and some frankly illogical plot points. The way characters speak to each other is juvenile at best and horribly unsubtle at worst. Ideas that could be left to the audience to grasp on their own are said in the most heavy-handed of ways. Alongside this, events happen in the movie that don’t really make logical or consistent sense and seem to only advance the plot forward. On the flip side some things happen and are implied by the film that are never expressly resolved and leave the viewing experience as sort of hollow.

Joker isn’t perfect, not by a long shot. It’s unsubtle, over-the-top, derivative, and messy. But it’s also intimate, shocking, haunting, and thought-provoking, even if not in the best way. While it has its flaws, there’s definitely a lot of merit in Todd Phillips attempt at providing a contemporary origin for a character without a definitive one. Even though it doesn’t always approach its core message with subtlety or grace, it at least has lofty ambitions of being socially conscious, and it reaches high enough to be a relatively enjoyable and intriguing theater experience long after the credits have rolled on Gotham City’s newest madman.

Joker gets ★★★ out of five.

-Chrishaun

Ad Astra Review – A Haunting Voyage Through Deep Space and Emotional Trauma

If you’re a son with a father somewhere out there, chances are this movie will make you cry

Despite only being 2 hours and 4 minutes long, Ad Astra feels like it’s over three hours. This isn’t negative, it’s not a criticism, but this movie takes its time. It meanders on plot details, it holds on shots and images, and we’re forced to sit and stew with a voice-over narration from Brad Pitt as he plumbs the depths of both mankind’s search for intelligent life as well as his own search for emotional control. The movie grabs the audience, locks them in the spacecraft with our main character, and expects us to absorb what’s being experienced on-screen, for better or worse.

And for me, it was all for the better. James Gray’s newest directorial outing is part of a long and storied history of existential science-fiction, a subgenre of sci-fi concerning humanity’s place in the universe and where we fit into the cosmic stew of it all. However, Ad Astra takes it a step further, and it is just as introspective as it is expansive. Equal parts Tarkovsky and Kubrick, and equal parts Coppola, the movie isn’t content with just looking to the stars for answers; it also expects us to find them amongst ourselves.

Ad Astra follows Brad Pitt as Roy McBride, the son of famed astronaut H. Clifford McBride, and a damn good one himself. He’s tasked with traveling to Mars to establish contact with his long-thought dead father; the lone survivor of the “Lima Project,” a US-manned expedition sent to discover intelligent life that was lost somewhere near Neptune. The reason for the contact is due to the fact that the Lima Project is somehow emitting massive power surges, destroying technology and posing a massive threat to human life. This news, of course, shakes Roy to the core and opens him up to an emotional vulnerability that he hasn’t experienced in years.

The centerpiece of the movie, moreso than the screenplay or even James Gray’s directing, is undoubtedly Brad Pitt’s performance as Roy. He’s the most consistent presence on-screen, sometimes isolated with nothing but his thoughts for long stretches of time. Roy is known for his complete composure in high-risk situations, and is able to keep his heart rate normal in even the most stressful events. However, the trade-off and the thematic undercurrent to his character is that he’s emotionally unavailable; distant, prone to a lack of communication and vulnerability that actually destroyed his marriage to his wife Eve, played in glimpses by Liv Tyler. Brad Pitt takes this all in stride and fuses these elements together to create a portrait of a man quietly toiling away in a self-imposed hell; one in which he’s acutely aware of his need for connection and companionship but unable to form those connections due to his baggage.

Alongside Pitt, there are several notable actors in this film who aren’t indicated to be here at all, so much so that I feel like listing them off would be kind of a spoiler and also a disservice to the film. Just know that Gray’s assembled a stacked cast that operate in different facets and different contexts. Some faces may be familiar for all of five seconds while some faces you might recognize have roles vitally important to the film’s endgame.

On top of the stellar casting and performances, the movie shines in its exceptional cinematography and sound design. Very rarely do the technical elements of filmmaking accurately represent the logistics of space operations, but Ad Astra takes care to try and do so. The grandiose and epic nature of space has never before been showcased in such isolated yet breathtaking beauty, and complimenting that is the meticulous sound editing. For all the time we’re alone with Roy and his thoughts, the sound design works tirelessly to give the impression of that bubble, that echo chamber that is man in isolation against the ever-expanding tangible quiet of space.

All of these things come together in service of the movie’s strongest theme: the need for humanity to value interpersonal connection. Roy McBride is a hollow and emotionally distant shell of a man, deep-diving into his own work in order to distract from the fact that he’s unfulfilled. However, it doesn’t take long for us to realize that this is part of a distinctly masculine cycle: Roy’s father left for the Lima Project because he was similarly unsatisfied. The thought of intelligent life in the universe was an easy ideal to replace his own need for human connection. At the root of its core, Ad Astra is a movie about our psychological need for connection, for companionship, and even more specific than that, about our need to break the cycle of toxic masculinity. Fathers need to do better for their sons, so that they can grow up in a world fully cognizant of the importance of each other.

Because at the end of the day, we’re really all we’ve got.

Ad Astra gets 4 astronaut Brad Pitts out of 5.

-Chrishaun

It: Chapter Two Review – Long and Messy and Entertaining in Equal Measure

Look, in retrospect, it could’ve been so much worse…

Pennywise is back in It: Chapter Two, the long-awaited sequel to 2017’s horror knockout. He’s crazier, he’s wittier, and he’s…hungrier? Yes. By a lot. In fact, Pennywise eats a record total of *SPOILER ALERT* two different children in this film. That tidbit of information really doesn’t affect the quality of the movie in any way, I’m just awestruck at the fact that we’re releasing movies in 2019 that show us not just one, but two different kids being devoured brutally by killer clowns on-screen. Just think about that for a second. I mean, two?! Did the miniseries even get away with one?

It: Chapter Two sees the Losers Club coming back together after 27 years outside the town of Derry, where they’re forced to reconcile with each of their own terrifying childhood trauma in order to defeat the being that’s been terrorizing them once and for all. Surprisingly, child-eating isn’t the only thing this sequel has more of. There are more scares, more laughs, more Stephen King Easter eggs and references, as well as more minutes, as the sequel clocks in at 2 hours and 50 minutes, a whole 24 minutes longer than the original. However, while the movie has more overall, I’d argue that it makes for less of a quality experience.

Right off the bat though, the movie’s strongest aspect is the ensemble. The young Losers of the first film were arguably the best part, and here we have the same thing again. Each of the actors cast to play the Losers older counterparts are spot-on here, as everyone feels like a distinct evolution of who those characters would be in adulthood. However, the particular standouts are definitely Bill Hader’s Richie, Jessica Chastain’s Beverly, and James Ransome’s Eddie. Each of them shape the film’s strong emotional core, with Bill Hader especially delivering a performance that’s equal parts wheezily hilarious and tenderly vulnerable in an unexpected way. It’s a welcome surprise that I wasn’t anticipating; having never read the book I was vaguely aware that the final half of the story was emotional and sentimental, but the movie adds a wholly original layer on top of it and pulls it off relatively gracefully, and the performances are definitely part of that.

Bill Skarsgård is also predictably awesome as Pennywise, with every movement and inflection designed to be both unpredictable and terrifying. Even though his acting is stellar, the character here feels a little flat in comparison to his debut in Chapter One, solely because of the fact that it doesn’t really feel like he’s changed or grown at all since the last time we saw him. In the climax of the first film, the Losers’ figure out that their friendship is their greatest weapon against him, and they literally and metaphorically kick his ass, sending him on the retreat for the next 27 years. You’d think after such a humiliating defeat he’d be either on the defensive or violently offensive; either afraid or even more fear-inducing. Instead he feels like the same playful trickster from the first movie; never really fully committed to killing any of our main heroes as much as he is playing around with them.

And the way he does so can only be described as “corny.” Despite a lack of genuine scares being a common criticism of the first film, I legitimately believe that there are some truly effective sequences in Chapter One. With Chapter Two I never felt any real sense of horror or suspense as each scene was either ridiculously CGI-heavy or played up for laughs and levity as opposed to real tension. Even with its R-Rating, the movie at times feels more juvenile than the recent PG-13 Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark, choosing to craft horror out of giant statues of Paul Bunyan and rehashing scenes from the first film instead of digging deep to find new and inventive ways to scare both the Losers and the audience.

In my opinion though, the weakest aspect of the film is the plot. I’m not sure if the book is the same way, but the second act of the film really drags, meandering from nostalgic setpiece to nostalgic setpiece as we follow the adult Losers searching for artifacts from their past, while also dodging Pennywise and his attempts to single each of them out. The editing and pacing are totally out of wack, and each scene feels the same: character ends up in iconic location from the first film, flashback to them as a child, cheesy Pennywise scare. It feels like the movie doesn’t think that the modern-day narrative can stand on its own, so it relies a number of unnecessary and convoluted flashbacks to bring back the original child actors. And while it’s cool to see and they all feel just as charismatic as they did the first time around, it’s also precious time that could have been used to flesh out the characterizations of the adult Losers. The entire structure of the storytelling feels disjointed, going so far as to even break Henry Bowers out of a mental institution only for him to do…nothing, really.

The ending of the film is also unable to fully stick the landing, however I can’t necessarily fault the filmmakers considering how notoriously weird and metaphysical King’s original ending is. Both Chapter One and Chapter Two have struggled on how to give the Losers a real, tangible way to defeat Pennywise on-screen, and while neither make a ton of logical sense, neither ruins the experiences of what came before. In fact, the ending of the movie may honestly be one of its best parts, as the final fifteen minutes are a whirlwind of well-earned emotional payoffs that make the previous 2 hours and 35 minutes totally worthwhile. It all culminates in an emotional resolution that’s both cathartic and heartwarming.

It: Chapter Two has a ton of problems, but then again, so do many of Stephen King’s stories and lots of horror in general. I’d advise watching it back-to-back with the first installment, as it relies heavily on the first film in a way that paradoxically feels lackluster as well as satisfying. While its flaws prevent it from coming together as a proper film that can stand on its own, it also manages to be a technically well-made and emotionally resonant sequel that compliments its predecessor.

It: Chapter Two gets 3 traumatized Losers out of five.

-Chrishaun

Ready or Not – A Familiar Yet Hilarious Wedding Night Thriller

Maybe getting married really isn’t all it’s cracked up to be

Marriage. That age-old institution; for some the moment their entire lives have been building towards, for others a ball and chain. Regardless on your viewpoints on it, there’s no questioning the fact that afterwards, everything changes. And part of that change is the fact that two families are joining as one, metaphorically, into something entirely new. This can be scary, but most times it’s rewarding, heartwarming, and wholly satisfying.

Unless, of course, you’re marrying into the Le Domas family.

This is the lesson learned far too late by our main character, Grace (played with just the right amount of roughness and attitude by Samara Weaving). She’s a blushing bride who’s just officiated her marriage to Alex, a quiet young man and one of several heirs to the Le Domas gaming empire, a massive sprawling fortune built atop boxes upon boxes of licensing-safe board games (I’m not exactly sure how lucrative this industry is in 2019). Along with the traditional feelings of alienation and apprehension that comes with meeting your in-laws for the first time, Grace discovers that the Le Domas’ follow a distinctly unusual tradition: on every wedding night, the newest addition to the family is required to play a game. Pick checkers, chess, or even Uno and you might have a good time. But unfortunately for Grace, she picks Hide and Seek, which launches her headfirst into a game of life and death as her once welcoming in-laws quickly turn into hunters and killers.

(L to R) Kristian Bruun, Melanie Scrofano, Andie MacDowell, Henry Czerny, Nicky Guadagni, Adam Brody, and Elyse Levesque in the film READY OR NOT. Photo by Eric Zachanowich. © 2019 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation All Rights Reserved

The story of Ready or Not isn’t a contender for Best of the Year. A lot of the plot points are recycled and a little predictable, and while the movie is complete with its own set of twists and turns, I’d be lying if I said the movie was wholly original. There’s tons of recognizable elements here, from the horrific out-of-touch ignorance of the Armitage clan in Get Out, to the white-knuckled bottle-thriller elements of a film like Don’t Breathe. Even some of the gaming motifs feel at home in a Saw-esque puzzle thriller. This is a fault, but only to a degree.

The reasons why Ready or Not‘s derivative story doesn’t hold it back are multi-faceted, but honestly, the biggest is the humor. The screenplay for this movie is absolutely hilarious. Writers Guy Busick and Ryan Christopher Murphy (no, not that one) very clearly understand the dark humor underlying the surface of the film’s premise, and they wield it like the sharpened battle axe used by Helene, the aunt of the Le Domas family. They successfully egg the audience into laughing at things we know are terrible, yet deathly funny anyway. The tone of the film never falters in its precise balance of its competing genres; the comedy wedges perfectly in the horror and vice-versa.

Aiding the screenplay are some particularly solid performances, with Samara Weaving at the head. She truly conveys the distinction between Grace and the family that she’s, for better or worse, about to become a part of. A big part of the conflict between them is their massive class separation; Grace truly feels and acts like a normal, low-to-middle class human being, complete with the snark and distrust most, if not all of us have, for those in the 1%. The Le Domas’ are also exceptionally cast, with the major standouts being Adam Brody as Daniel Le Domas, Alex’s conflicted and brooding younger brother, as well as Melanie Scrofano as Emilie Le Domas, the spoiled and uptight young daughter of the family, with a horribly timed trigger finger.

While the comedy of the film is borderline perfect, the thriller elements also work for the most part. The film is well-shot with layered and inviting camera framing, and the editing maintains a breakneck pace that carries us from frantic setpiece to setpiece. We truly feel Grace’s desperation to escape, and the only time the movie really breaks that desperation and frenzy is when the screenplay requires that Grace make silly or illogical mistakes in order to carry on the plot. This does happen more than once, and while it took me out of the movie each time, it wasn’t nearly enough to severely hurt my enjoyment of it.

Similarly in the vein of movies like Get Out, Ready or Not also tries to cut its teeth on social commentary. This time however, instead of racially tone-deaf in-laws, they’re rich, morally bankrupt billionaires. This feels totally topical (one can only wonder why) and the film does a really great job playing up the humor in their simultaneous ignorance of the lower class as well as their sheer cruelty. For the Le Domas’, their horrible acts are just another rung in the ladder, a necessary evil required to maintain their status quo. The movie doesn’t drive home that theme in a particularly impactful way, but the subtlety at which they poke and prod at it is more than enough for a film who’s primary concern seems to be a vehicle for darkly comic entertainment.

Ready or Not, despite its seeming lack of originality, is still a breath of fresh air. It’s a tightly written, technically-sound, and dynamically acted piece of filmmaking. It won’t blow you away with its incredible plot structure or wriggle around in your brain for weeks with its “eat the rich” commentary, but it’s certainly an hour and thirty-five minutes well-spent. If you’re a fan of comedies that make you question your moral compass, frantic horror-thrillers, or a good time at the movie with a group of friends, you will be immensely satisfied.

Ready or Not gets 3 1/2 regretfully employed maids out of 5.

-Chrishaun