The quasi-sequel to the seminal 1985 masterwork isn’t just a meditation on America’s current racial climate, but how that atmosphere is directly informed by America’s hidden past. *SPOILERS*
“Nothing ends, Adrian. Nothing ever ends.”
Those words, within the 12th issue of Alan Moore’s classic work of superhero metafiction, Doctor Manhattan sows the first seeds of doubt into the mind of Adrian Veidt, the World’s Smartest Man, after the latter has murdered millions of innocent people in an effort to save humankind from itself. It’s the first real sliver of insecurity in an otherwise totally confident mind, and it reinforces the central question of issue 12 (ironically titled ‘A Stronger Loving World’), which is whether or not Adrian Veidt’s plan can truly save humanity, or are we doomed to fall back into a cycle of destruction and violence due to our human nature?

Then came HBO’s Watchmen, a quasi-sequel to the original set in the modern day helmed by Damon Lindelof, which swaps out masked vigilantes for masked cops, Richard Nixon for Hollywood icon Robert Redford, and the looming threat of nuclear annihilation with the ever-present shadow of white supremacy. And it’s there, in this dichotomy, that we receive a response to the statement posed back in 1985. Nothing ever ends, truly, and this includes America’s natural-born relationship with its history of racial violence.
For context: HBO’s Watchmen follows the story of Sister Night, real name Angela Abar, a police officer in Tulsa, Oklahoma, where the cops wear masks to protect their identities in the aftermath of a domestic terrorist attack perpetrated against the Tulsa PD. The perpetrators? The Seventh Kavalry, a homegrown racist militia who were inspired by the publication of Rorschach’s Journal to don his mask and take up arms. The show’s central mystery is posed when Police Chief Judd Crawford is murdered by an unknown assailant at the end of the pilot episode.
Lindelof and his writers took very specific care to ingrain the show in America’s history much in the same way as the graphic novel, and one of the ways they did this was by opening the pilot episode with an on-the-ground depiction of the Tulsa massacre that occurred on May 31st, 1921, all from the eyes of a young boy named Will Reeves. For those who haven’t seen the show or aren’t aware, the Tulsa massacre was a horrific event in American history, in which a group of 1500 whites descended upon the Greenwood neighborhood of Tulsa and razed it to the ground, causing thousands of dollars worth of property damage. The Tulsa Police Department’s “official” tally of the dead was 36 people, including 10 whites. Before the massacre, Greenwood was an affluent neighborhood in which black Americans thrived and prospered. The area was even christened the “Black Wall-Street.” However, it took Greenwood years to rebuild in the face of the massacre, and Tulsa was never the same.

Within the universe of the show, the Tulsa massacre was eventually the defining event that led to the establishment of ‘Redfordations’ – a legislation that gave tax cuts to descendants of the people directly affected by the event. However, in the real world, the Tulsa race massacre was covered up and left unspoken for decades afterwards. The Tulsa Tribune, the local newspaper that inadvertently started the massacre by falsely reporting an alleged sexual assault of a white woman by a young black teenager, destroyed all recorded stories about the event from their bound volumes. Tulsa police and state militia archives about the incident were also decidedly omitted, causing teachings of the event to be left out of the American school system until very recently. In fact, it wasn’t until 1997 that an official state government commission was established to investigate the Tulsa riot. In 2001, an official published report from the Tulsa Race Massacre Commission concluded that between 100 and 300 black Americans were murdered during the event, an unfathomable leap from the originally reported 36.
The massacre looms heavy over the rest of the show, but it isn’t until episode 6, ‘This Extraordinary Being,’ that the event’s true relevance revealed itself to the show and to the mythos of Watchmen as a whole. Will Reeves, the young survivor of the Tulsa massacre and Angela’s recently discovered grandfather, is actually Hooded Justice, turned onto the path of vigilantism by the discovery that the New York police department that he worked for was filled to the brim with racial corruption. Hooded Justice, within the context of the original graphic novel, is the first costumed adventurer to spring onto the scene back in 1938 and directly inspired the Minutemen, and by proxy, the events of the book. His identity was never revealed in-universe as he disappeared shortly after the disbanding of the Minutemen, and speculation surrounded him in fan circles right up until the show premiered.

This is a massive change to the lore of Moore and Gibbons’ original book, one that fits neatly in the blank space left by his character, and one that is fraught with implications of appropriation as survival and white hegemony. The idea that a bisexual black man, angry at the world for its vicious treatment of him, directly inspired the actions of costumed vigilantes for the next five decades is a powerful one, and a strikingly ironic parallel to the now-infamous 2017 interview in which Alan Moore states that superheroes are white supremacist power fantasies. However, I think the most noteworthy implication of Will’s vigilantism and trauma is the effect that it may have indirectly had on Angela, as part of the recurring nature of America’s past.
There have been several studies, the most recent examining the connective tissue between survivors of Civil War POW camps and their descendants, that seem to suggest that a history of trauma and PTSD can be passed down through generations, creating an effect on both mental and physical health. It’s worth noting that these studies aren’t conclusive by any means, but there’s enough evidence to suggest the possibility that trauma may be embedded in the DNA of your descendants, and if that’s the case, is it possible that young black Americans hold that very same trauma within our DNA? That experiences shared by our ancestors shape our views of the world to this very day? And if that’s the case, is the implication that our experiences will shape our descendants?
Can this same argument be made about Angela and Will? Did Will’s experiences in the 30s lead to Angela’s current day temperament? Did the mask Will donned back then lead to the mask Angela wears now? Both of them, transcending decades, have fought against racial violence and white supremacy, and both of them have tried to find healing and catharsis through violence and anger. And while black retaliation is justified, it seems as if the show argues that living in that anger only leads to more pain. It seems that the final question the show leaves us with, moreso than whether or not Manhattan’s powers really were in that egg, is whether or not there’s a way for them to escape the trauma that they now both share?

On top of this, there’s another side to the show’s depiction of America’s cyclical racial violence. While the Seventh Kavalry are depicted as racists hiding behind the familiar inkblot mask of everyone’s favorite proto-fascist vigilante, we discover in episode 6 that the Seventh Kavalry have a precursor in Cyclops, a racist offshoot organization of the KKK that Will discovered was rooted within the very foundation of the NYPD. In retaliation, Will tried his hardest to root them out, even going as far as to kill several of their high-ranking members and burn down the base of their operation. But unbeknownst to him, the organization festers, until he finds out that it’s been co-opted by none other than Senator Joe Keene and Chief Judd Crawford, the two engineers of the White Night attacks on police and the resulting masked cop legislation. Both Will and Angela learn the hard way that America’s past doesn’t die, it just resurfaces, more palatable but still just as sinister.
As we find out in the final three episodes, this time their plan is much larger in scale. “It’s a really difficult time to be a white man in America,” Keene tells Special Agent Laurie Blake, while getting ready to step into a prototype intrinsic field generator, one eerily familiar to the same machine built in Gila Flats, New Mexico over four decades earlier. “So I figured I’d become a blue one.” It’s hard to deny how eerily similar Keene’s phrasing sounds to rhetoric used by members of the alt-right, in their declaration that modern day progressive ideologies have made it increasingly dangerous to exist as a white man in America. From concerns about becoming the new minority to shouts of “you will not replace us,” young white men are becoming increasingly aggressive when faced with the fact that they’re no longer being catered to.

Moderates across both aisles will tell you that this is new. Conservatives will say that this started with Obama, that his “race pandering” and indulgence of “hate groups” like Black Lives Matter created a toxic miasma of racial tensions that didn’t exist before. Liberals will say that these groups felt emboldened by Donald Trump and his indulging of his nationalist fanbase; the Richard Spencers and David Dukes of the world. But the real truth, the ugly truth, is that, just like the Cyclops, racism in America never truly went away. These new hate groups might wear new faces, but the truth is they’re just new symptoms of the same institutional problem America has allowed to fester for years. The same police structure that allowed the Tulsa massacre is the same police structure now fostering the murder of young black men. These occurrences may be new to some people, but for black Americans, this hate, this hurt, this pain has always been there.
Despite being a mirror to our own twisted timeline, Watchmen offers no easy answers. Adrian Veidt dropped a fake alien on New York and killed millions, and still couldn’t put a dent in the inevitability of human nature. Will Reeves fought for years against racism and white superiority, only to discover that his age old enemy had morphed before his very eyes, like an inkblot on a Rorschach test. Everything cycles back in on itself, like the ouroboros, eating its own tail. And America, as it seems, is doomed to repeat itself again and again.
That is, unless we expose its history to the masses. If we refuse to allow the injustices perpetrated to go unknown and unnamed as they have. Just like the truth of the Tulsa massacre was revealed, almost 8 decades after it happened, the rest of America’s past needs to be exhumed and put under the microscope, to be examined, discussed, absorbed, and understood. For us to attempt to address our racial divide, we must first accept that it’s always been here. It didn’t start in 2016, it didn’t start in the 1960’s, and it didn’t start in Tulsa in 1921. America has always worn a mask to hide its true face from the world and it’s people.
And just like Will Reeves so beautifully said in the show’s final episode, “You can’t heal under a mask Angela. Wounds need air.”
-Chrishaun




































